Menu Close

Month: July 2013

Confession #39: I Wish Who Was More Diverse

It can be easy to wax poetic about the ways in which Doctor Who shows us how to be tolerant of those who are different and the heartache that follows when people think only of themselves. Like Star Trek has traditionally done on this side of the Pond, our show often serves to promote understanding among people of different backgrounds and make us think critically about our common assumptions.

Maybe that’s one reason it makes me sad to realize how homogeneous its characters are.

Think about it. How many characters have been people of color (that is, colors other than green!)? Or people with demonstrably other-than-heterosexual orientations (or any other minority identity one could name)? Of those, how many were major players? We’ve only had one Companion (or two, if you count Mickey, which I really don’t) who was a POC. Granted, now and then there’s a one-off POC character (like Rita in The God Complex or Nasreen in The Hungry Earth/Cold Blood), but they don’t stick around. Similarly, no one but Captain Jack is blatantly “omnisexual.” (I know Moffat’s stated that River is bi, but the fact that he had to tell us means she’s not represented that way on screen.) And given the demographics of the UK (because, let’s be honest, as a British show, it’s going to reflect British culture), you’d think there would be more POC/non-heteronormative/etc. characters even among the extras.

Confession #38: I’m Sick of Fan-Bashing

I am so bloody tired of fans bashing each other.

It seems everywhere I turn, someone in fandom is putting down someone else. “Old Skool Fans are horrible, stuck-up, un-inclusive twits who are policing the fandom.” “Anybody who likes/misses Tennant is an over-sexed teenage girl who wouldn’t know either quality storytelling or good acting if it bit her in the ass.”

Obviously both the complaints above are simultaneously overstated (though not much) and erroneous. Yes, there are things that irritate me about the new breed of “fangirls”—those who only love Ten (especially the hardcore Ten/Rose shippers) or only love Eleven. There are also things that really piss me off about the oh-so-superior long-term fans. But frankly, I’m sick and tired of everyone bitching about how their own brand of fandom is better, and anyone who disagrees with them is an idiot.

Seriously. I am just done with other fans shitting on “Tennant fangirls.” I’m not saying I like fans who only watch the show for Tennant, lobby for his return as the next Doctor, and badmouth anyone else who plays the role. I think they’re missing some wonderful stuff, and only hurting themselves by not bothering even to try anything else.

But that’s the point—that’s my opinion, not theirs.

Burn Baby Burn

Review of Inferno: SE (#54)

DVD Release Date: 11 Jun 13
Original Air Date: 09 May – 20 Jun 1970
Doctor/Companion: Three, Dr. Elizabeth “Liz” Shaw, Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
Stars: Jon Pertwee, Caroline John, Nicholas Courtney
Preceding Story: The Ambassadors of Death (Three, Liz, the Brigadier)
Succeeding Story: Terror of the Autons (Three, Jo, the Brigadier)

It seems strange to me that despite how much I love this serial, I’ve never actually given Inferno a proper review before. I count it among my Top 3 pre-Hiatus favorites and have recommended it often to those who want to try out new-to-them earlier Doctors (as long as they can handle a seven-part serial), so I was thrilled a few months ago to see it pop up on the list of upcoming Special Edition releases.

I was further thrilled when I realized June had seen the release of two stories written by Don Houghton (the other being The Mind of Evil). It’s only as I’ve gotten more deeply entrenched in Whovian culture that I’ve paid attention to such details. (I used to watch television and simply take what I saw on screen as it came, passing judgment in terms of “I do/don’t like this,” but not paying the least attention to writers, directors, and such. Go figure.) But I feel the richer for it; I have a new appreciation for why MoE worked for me, knowing my fondness for Inferno.

So what’s so hot (see what I did there?) about Inferno anyway? Well, for one thing, it throws in a beautiful idea not really seen in Doctor Who up to this point: that of an alternate universe. I love the way we get to see little personality differences between familiar characters and their counterparts in the parallel dimension. The supporting cast is brilliant, not least the stellar (if regrettably named) Olaf Pooley as Professor Stahlman. Despite some pretty “out there” plot developments, the whole cast plays everything straight, and you can’t help believe in their experiences and reactions. If nothing else, the administrative red tape that ties Sir Keith Gold’s hands from doing anything useful to prevent impending disaster adds a sense of (slightly depressing) realism.

Eighties Incarnate

Review of The Doctors Revisited – Sixth Doctor

We’ve arrived at our median Doctor, by number the midpoint of his Regenerations to date. If you’re not familiar with “Old Sixie” (as his actor Colin Baker calls him now), you’re in for quite the ride.

I think more than any other, Six is a break from what we’re used to associating with “the Doctor.” In stark contrast to his immediate predecessor—the mellow, folksy, human one—this Doctor epitomizes the alpha-male aspects of his personalities (brash, show-off, egotistical…). As Moffat (who is joined here by fellow interviewees Marcus Wilson, Colin Baker, Nicola Bryant, Bonnie Langford, Nicholas Briggs, and Dan Starkey) observed, Six cared about being paid attention to and about being listened to, but not about being liked (if you have any doubt, just look at that over-the-top, oh-so-’80s, coat of many colors). He would do what he felt he needed to do and not care one whit about whose feelings he might hurt along the way.

That’s not to say he didn’t care; he was actually quite compassionate. It’s simply that his definitions of right and wrong in a given situation don’t necessarily line up with what his Companion or the audience—humans, in other words—would think.

Fandom Feels the Love

As we inch ever closer to the 50th anniversary of Doctor Who in November, more and more little nods to this cultural icon and its fans are cropping up. One of my new favorite such instances is the wonderful fan-written ode to the show titled Celebrate Regenerate.

This 300-page book is a multi-part love letter to the entire run of Doctor Who, written by a wide range of fans at the behest of editor Lewis Christian. The idea began in mid-2012, when Christian began soliciting submissions in a thread on the Gallifrey Base forum. Before he knew it, he was getting retweets from the editor of Doctor Who Magazine, writers, actors, and others closely associated with the show. Pieces began pouring in, until he hardly knew what to do with them all.

Nearly a year later, there are articles covering every televised story from An Unearthly Child through The Name of the Doctor; artwork of five decades of Doctors, Companions, and foes (including the cover seen here, by Alejandra Ramírez Giraldo); and special features from interviews to speculative theories to an overview of where else the show has gone, off-screen.

One of the most unique and wonderful attributes of the book is that since contributors could choose which episodes they wanted to discuss, every single article (including three by me) is written from the perspective of someone who loves the story in question. So that one that everyone loves to hate? Guess what—someone else thinks it's the bees knees! Or your guilty pleasure? You're not alone!

Find the relevant page for any one story that you don't care for, and read what the other fans have written. I challenge you to come away without at least once nodding and saying, "well, okay, they've got a point there." And fans are not fools; someone reviewing an oft-reviled tale will acknowledge its flaws while making a persuasive argument that it's actually pretty awesome in its way even so. It is this attitude on every page that makes the collection exactly what it says on the cover: a celebration.

If I've piqued your interest (and hopefully I have), you can get your own copy of Celebrate, Regenerate either as a free PDF download or in paper (at cost, via Lulu) through the official website. It's out today!